Heartbreak Inside Jeremy’s Fort!

Aaron Miller and Serena Maxwell break it off.
Aaron Miller and Serena Maxwell break it off.

Where there’s drama, there’s drama!  Our spies were at 54 Below recently and witnessed a breakup of epic proportions.  Serena Maxwell and Aaron Miller have called it quits.  Why?  Because apparently there’s another woman in Aaron’s life.  And not just any woman, she’s Penny Reilly – currently appearing alongside Maxwell in Jeremy’s Fort!

Witnesses reported seeing a very close, intimate conversation between Reilly and Miller while Miller’s supposed girlfriend was on stage singing with another man.  Here’s where it got interesting – after the song, Maxwell approached Miller and Reilly at the bar where it became obvious that something was not right.  Maxwell stormed out, along with her singing partner and the more obvious fact that things are through is that Miller didn’t chase after her.

The bartender, who said we could refer to him as Bixby, was working mere feet from this disaster confirmed the details of the conversation.

This all comes on the heels of Miller spending some serious time away in CT, where we can only assume he was getting away from Maxwell.  Big questions remain.

How will this alter the chemistry between Maxwell and Reilly on stage for Jeremy’s Fort?  Are Miller and Reilly an item?  Is Maxwell going to rebound with this mysterious other man (who’s quite the singer, btw)?  As soon as we know, you’ll know.

12 Responses

  1. Joan Pidomski
    |

    So sad! I thought they made a really cute couple. Who is this Penny girl anyway?!

  2. Jon
    |

    Wait, Serena Maxwell is single?! Yesssssssss.

  3. Anonymous
    |

    Yeah, like you have a shot with Serena Maxwell.

  4. Jill P.
    |

    Has anyone seen Jeremy’s Fort? The rumor is that it’s amazing.

  5. d.
    |

    Aaron and Penny forever!

  6. Julie
    |

    If this is true, I feel bad for Serena Maxwell. Can’t be easy going on stage next to the ‘other woman’ that lied to you.

  7. Patrick P.
    |

    I heard that one of the Giddyup guys stormed out of a talkback session.

    • Sam
      |

      that must have been really bad…….. I wonder if they’re known for storming out and possibly having a bad reputation for it

  8. Sam
    |

    I heard that Reilly and Maxwell are now on speaking terms and that Aaron is in a relationship with Penny and is going to law school in New york

    • Giddyup
      |

      I know them personally and yes–they storm out a lot. They’re really very much like 2 year olds–except they walk really well.

  9. Sarah C.
    |

    Wait Penny from the Mean Girls incident? I’m glad she’s back on her feet and has Aaron there to help her. She could have had better timing though

  10. Annaleigh
    |

    Yass!!! She was SOOO good in Mean Girls! I’m so proud of her for Jeremy’s Fort too!!! That show NEEDS to move to Broadway.